Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (USA) AND NIGERIA IN RESOLUTION OF CORPORATE DISPUTE

Abstract

Conflict is defined in ordinary parlance to mean inability to agree on a particular issue or position between two or more persons. It is found everywhere. It is part and parcel of human existence. What causes conflict in any given situation varies amongst individuals or corporate organizations. The objective of this study is not necessarily to dwell into details on what causes conflict in corporate organizations. The research is primarily aimed at finding a more flexible and better approach to resolution of corporate disputes in Nigeria. This   required doing a comparative study of corporate dispute resolution practices in Nigeria with that of the United States America, whose model is essentially the Alternative Dispute Resolution models. This approach to resolution of corporate disputes took a radical departure from the old method whereby workers drag corporate disputes between themselves and corporate organisations to court for settlement. Even though there are local framework for peaceful resolution of trade corporate disputes in Nigeria,  coupled with the recent innovations to fastrack justice administration, (such as the establishment of the National Industrial Courts, the new civil procedure rules, the establishment of the multi-door-court houses, the use of technology? and time line given to judges to dispense with matters expeditiottsly) it has not solve the problem of achieving, a very effective quick and vibrant justice delivery m Nigeria In the 2015 Judges conference that was held in Abuja the Vice President  of the Federal Republic of Nigeria Professor  Yewi Osinbajo  stated quite emphatically that the Nigerian legal process is extremely slow in resolutions of disputes and needs to be over-hauled very urgently. In the United States of America, the scenario is different. They have what is called the Public Resources Act which prevents corporate bodies from resorting to litigation to resolve corporate disputes without first exhausting one of fee several Alternative Dispute Resolutions methods that is peculiar to a particular dispute. This is not the case with Nigeria. Today MTN and National Communication Commission are locked up in a titanic legal battle over the payment of fines and a single cowl order could jeopardize the operations of the company. The economic and social consequences of such act can only he imagined, in the face of the prevailing economic recession the need to adopt the American method in resolution of corporate disputes became the gravamen of this research. The ADR method as it is popularly called involves different techniques of resolving disputes. It could be by way of arbitration or conciliation, mediation or negotiation or other methods as the case may be. In this study, most of these processes were examined including litigation. Their workings and challenges in resolution of corporate disputes in the United States and Nigeria, was equally examined. By so doing, it was discovered that the American model and templates is simplier, faster and better and was therefore recommended. The research methodology involved in the research was the doctrinal and soda-legal approach The scope is a comparative study of the corporate disputes resolution processes in the United States and Nigeria with occasional reference to the UK This was done without prejudice to the fact that not all disputes are resolved through ADR methods in general.

Keywords

Comparative Analysis, Resolution, Corporate Dispute

PDF